KV-4 (Object 224) Marishkin

Soviet Union (1941)
Super Heavy Tank – Blueprints Only

The KV-4 program was started in March 1941 to deal with alleged new heavy tank advances by the German Reich. Development took place at the Leningrad Kirov Factory design bureau SKB-2 headed by J.Y. Kotin. A design competition was held, with over 27 different design proposals. While many designs were appreciated for their innovative features, even more were disregarded. One of these was proposed by engineer F.A. Marishkin, who’s design featured a large complex turret and an unremarkable hull.

Development

–Dear reader: A more detailed development analysis of the KV-4 program can be found in the KV-4 Dukhov article–

KV-4 designs

Placement	Name	Drawings	Mass (t)	Dimensions (m) (LxWxH)	Armament	Crew	Top speed (theoretical)	Armor	Reward /Rubles
1	Dukhov KV-4		82.5	8.150 3.790 3.153	107 mm ZiS-6 45 mm K-20 2x 7.62 mm DT machine guns	6	40 km/h	Front top plate: 135 mm Front bottom plate: 130 mm Side plate: 125 mm Top and belly: 40 mm	5000
2	Kuzmin, Tarotko, Tarapatin KV-4		88	9.26 3.78 3.175	107 mm ZiS-6 45 mm K-20 2x 7.62 mm DS-39 machine guns	6	36 km/h	Front: 125 mm Side: 125-100 mm Top and belly: 40 mm	3000
3	Tseits KV-4		90	8.85 4.03 3.62	107 mm ZiS-6 2x 7.62 mm DS-39 machine guns Unspecified flamethrower	7	45 km/h	Front hul upper plate: 50 mm Front hull bottom plate: 125 mm Turret:130 mm Side plate: 125 mm Top and belly: 50 mm	2800
4	Sychev KV-4		95 – 100	9.23 4.00 3.40	107 mm ZiS-6 (F-42) 45 mm 20-K 2x 7.62 mm DT machine guns	6	40 – 45	Turret: 135-125 mm Hull: 105 mm Top and belly: 40 mm	2000
4	Ermolaev KV-4		90	8.22 4.00 3.25	107 mm ZiS-6	6	35	130 mm
			95	8.52 4.00 3.25	107 mm ZiS-6 45 mm 20-K	6	35	130 mm	2000
5	Shashmurin KV-4		92	9.50 4.00 3.85	107 mm ZiS-6 (F-42) main cannon (112 or 102 rounds) 76 mm F-11 secondary cannon (120 rounds) 2x 7.62 mm DT machine guns (400 rounds) Unspecified flamethrower (hull)	7	35 km/h	Front top plate: 125 mm Side plate: 125 mm Top and belly: 50 to 40 mm	1500
6	Buganov KV-4		93	7.70 3.80 3.90	107 mm ZiS-6 45 mm 20-K	6	50 km/h	Front 125 mm	1000
6	Moskvin KV-4		101	9.573 4.03 3.74	107 mm ZiS-6 45 mm 20-K	6	40 km/h	Front 130 mm	1000
7	Pereverzev KV-4		100	9.5 3.8 3.82	107 mm ZiS-6 45 mm 20-K 2x 7.62 mm DT machine guns	6	39 km/h	Front: 125 mm	500
7	Bykov KV-4		98.6	9.5 4.03 3.65	107 mm ZiS-6 45 mm 20-K 7.62 mm DS-39 machine gun	8	36 km/h	Front 130 mm	500
7	Kalivod KV-4								500
N/A	Fedorenko KV-4		98.65	8.10 4.03 3.70	107 mm ZiS-6 45 mm M.1938 3x 7.62 mm DT machine guns Unspecified flamethrower	6	35 km/h	Front upper plate: 140 mm Side plate: 125 mm Turret: 125 mm Top and belly: 50 to 40 mm
N/A	Kreslavsky KV-4		92.6	9 4 3.225	107 mm ZiS-6 45 mm Mod.1937 20-K coaxial 3x 7.62 mm DT machine guns	6	45 km/h	Turret: 130 mm Front hull plate: 130 mm Front upper plate: 80 mm Side plate: 125 mm Rear plate: 130 mm Top /bottom: 50 -40 mm
N/A	Kruchenykh KV-4		107.7	9.13 4.03 3.78	107 mm ZiS-6 45 mm 20-K 4x 7.62 mm DT machine guns	9	30 km/h	Front: 130 mm
N/A	Mikhailov KV-4		86.5	9 3.6 3	107 mm ZiS-6 (F-42) 45 mm Mod.1937 20-K (hull-mounted) 3x 7.62 mm DT machine guns	6	50 km/h	Turret: 130 mm Hull: 130 mm Belly and belly: 50 – 40 mm
N/A	Marishkin KV-4		86.4	8.7 3.6 3.5	107 mm ZiS-6 45 mm 20-K	7	40 km/h	Front: 130 mm Upper frontal: 80 mm
N/A	Pavlov & Grigorev KV-4		91	8.5 4.0 3.6	107 mm ZiS-6 45 mm 20-K	6	45 km/h	Front: 100 – 125 mm
N/A	Turchaninov KV-4		89.5	9.8 4.0 3.0	107 mm ZiS-6 45 mm 20-K DT machine gun	7	35 km/h	Front: 125 mm
N/A	Strukov KV-4		92	8.6 4.0 3.8	107 mm ZiS-6 45 mm 20-K	6	50 km/h	Front: 80 – 130 mm
N/A	Unknown KV-4
N/A	Unknown KV-4

With the expansion of German aggression over Europe in 1940, Soviet leadership followed events with unease, despite their non-aggression pact with the German Reich, signed in August 1939. Their successful use of tanks was unprecedented and other nations rushed to expand their tank development and armament programs. During this time, the Soviets would start fielding the KV-1 heavy tank, based on experiences from the Winter War. However, it would quickly become apparent that it was rushed due to Stalin’s requests and still needed plenty of fine tuning. By the start of Operation Barbarossa, the KV-1 would still prove a lethal weapon, with excellent protection and adequate firepower, but was let down by significant quality, logistical and training problems.

On 11 March 1941, the Soviet Intelligence services submitted a report to the GABTU (Main Directorate of Armored Forces) regarding the development of German tanks. Most noticeable was the section on heavy tanks, where, amongst others developments akin to the VK.30.01(H) and VK.36.01(H), was the mention of a 90 tonne Mark VII tank, armed with a 105 mm gun, which is know now was some early variant of the later Pz.Kpfw.VII Löwe. This came as an unpleasant surprise to Soviet officials, who only had the aforementioned KV-1 and the hopelessly obsolete T-35 tank. The most advanced heavy tanks in development were the KV-150 (T-150), an improvement based on the KV-1 with 90 mm of frontal turret armor and total weight of 50 tonnes, and the KV-220, armed with an 85 mm F-30 gun, 100 mm of armor all-round, and total weight of over 60 tonnes. While both were very respectable on paper and superior to all German tanks of the time, they had reliability issues, with the KV-220 breaking two engines while testing, though the engine was equally unreliable and only two were built.

Thus, the GABTU set out to develop a new heavy tank to match the German tanks. On 21 March, they laid out all the requirements for the new heavy tank. It was to be armed with the new 107 mm ZiS-6 developed at Factory No.92 by V.G. Grabin. The armor was to be 130 mm to 120 mm all-round and a weight between 70 to 72 tonnes. Propulsion was set to be the M-40 diesel aviation engine with 4 TK-88 turbochargers. The tank was to be equipped with a vast array of secondary weapons as well, namely a 45 mm gun and at least three 7.62 mm machine guns, as well as a flamethrower.

Development of the KV-4 would take place at the LKZ (Kirov Leningrad Factory) SKB-2 design bureau, the same office responsible for all the previous KV tanks. Production of the first prototype was assigned to the Izhora plant, based on LKZ drawings. Thus, the tank was named KV-4 and received index Object 224. The project deadline was set to 17 July for the drawings and October for first prototype production.

Shortly after the initial release of the requirements, the GABTU edited their request, specifically on 7 April. Firstly, they would request a heavy upgrade of the KV-220, named KV-3, that would act as a stopgap until the heavier tanks were ready, armed with a 107 mm gun and 120 mm of frontal armor. Likewise, an even heavier tank was requested, named KV-5, with frontal armor thickness of 170 mm and side of 150 mm, and weight of at least 90 tonnes, also armed with the 107 mm ZiS-6. To better fit the KV-4 between the two new vehicles, its weight threshold was lifted to at least 75 tonnes, and 125 mm of armor at the sides. To increase the urgency of the matter, the deadline was tightened to 15 June.

Over at SKB-2 design bureau, which was headed by J.Y. Kotin, work would set on developing all 3 tanks. Interestingly, as a result of the loose requirements set by the military, Kotin would challenge his engineers to a design competition, in an attempt to bring out the most innovative ideas. With the approval of the factory director, I.M. Saltzman, Kotin was given the necessary funds to award the top designers with significant financial awards. Over 24 designers entered the competition, with just as many different concepts submitted. On the 9 May, the winners were announced, in first place being N.L. Dukhov, a trio of designers, K.I. Kuzmin, P.S. Tarapatin and V. I. Tarotko in second place and N.V. Tseits on third. In total, 11 designs and 13 engineers were awarded.

However after the competition was over, work on the KV-4 severely stagnated, to the point where Marshal of the Soviet Union G.I. Kulik had to personally come over and attempt to speed up the process, to no avail. Truth is, most of the efforts went to the KV-5, based on knowledge from the KV-4. Even so, the KV-5 was in a very early stage when the German Reich began their invasion of the Soviet Union, on 22 June 1941, and their quick advance into Soviet territory would put great strain on tank factories.

By September, the German forces were advancing towards Leningrad, and the SKB-2 design bureau was evacuated to ChTZ (Chelyabinsk Tractor Plant), which was renamed ChKZ (Chelyabinsk Kirov Plant), or as more commonly known, Tankograd. Unfortunately for the heavy KV designs, they were seen as a massive resource drain and work on them did not recommence.

F.A. Marishkin

Alongside 5 other engineers, F.A. Marishkin was head of the design of the transmission of the KV-1 while also being part of the design team of the SMK and T-150. After the war, he would continue working at the Kirov plant as one of the designers of the KT-12 forestry tractor, but also on the development stages of the T-10.

Design

Compared to the majority of the KV-4 designs presented, Marishkin’s can be seen as one of the more conservative ones in regards to general layout and design. What was essentially an enlarged KV-220 hull was mated to a very large main turret, with a secondary turret on top. The front of the hull was a ‘stepped’ design, consisting of a large lower plate, a steeply angled ‘hood’ followed by a flatter but thickened section in the armor connecting to the hull roof. The side armor was simply flat all along. The rear was very similar to the KV-1, consisting of two plates with a gap in between for engine cooling airflow. The main turret was mounted between the second and sixth roadwheels. Frontally, it consisted of a single plate stamped into a curved shape. The sides of the turret are not specifically drawn out on the blueprints, but they curved inwards at the rear, as well as being angled upwards for improved protection.

Perhaps the only unusual aspect of Marishkin’s design was the secondary turret, specifically its placement. It was towards the rear of the turret and offset to the right. As the main turret was curved and angled inwards, the secondary turret hung over the main turret walls, requiring a form of extension of the turret walls to support the turret ring. This certainly complicated the construction process.

The recoil distance of the ZiS-6 107 mm gun was not specified, but it is clear that, if the secondary turret was placed centrally, the gun recoil would slice the secondary turret gunner’s legs off (see KV-4 Kruchenykh). The only other option would have been extending the turret’s bustle size, but that might have not been possible considering balance and the limited turret ring size.

The engine used was a M-40 1,200 hp engine, originating from an aviation engine and capable of running on both diesel and kerosene. It had a V12 configuration, 61.07 liters displacement, and featured 4 TK-88 turbochargers. Fuel tanks were fitted alongside the hull sides and floor, underneath the turret.

The suspension was a standard KV series layout, with 8 steel-rimmed roadwheels sprung by torsion bars and with travel stops. The drive sprocket was at the back, connected to the brakes and final drive ensemble.

Crew

The crew on Marishkin’s proposal was 7, one more than the GABTU-specified 6. The exact layout and positions are unknown, but based on the tank layout and similar designs, the following can be concluded. The crew consisted of the driver, radio operator, main gunner, 2 main gun loaders, commander (which was also the secondary armament gunner), and secondary loader.

The driver would be seated (as seen in the drawing above) in the front of the hull. Next to him would be the operator of the 10-R tank radio.

The remaining 5 crewmembers would be seated in the turret. The main gunner was seated to the left of the gun, with a loader behind him. The other main loader was likely on the opposite side, to the right of the gun breech. The commander was seated to the left of the 45 mm secondary gun and the loader to the right.

This layout is purely speculation by the author, largely based on space, practicality, and other KV-4 designs with known crew positions. It could be argued that certain positions did not exist or should be rearranged, for example, the second main loader replaced with the tank commander and the secondary gun to receive its own designated gunner.

Armor

Like most of the pre-war Soviet heavy tanks, the armored plates were simply welded together without interlocking. A likely form of connection for the heavier plates was via pins, like on the German Maus tank. These would physically improve the connection between plates but could prove to further complicate the manufacturing process and cause weakening of the armor in those areas to be more susceptible to cracking and shattering.

The lower frontal plate was 130 mm thick, pressed into shape. The upper part of the armor consisted of a single plate, with the bottom being 80 mm thick and the top part 130 mm, pressed to form a steep hood and driver’s front plate. The side was a single flat 120 mm thick plate. The turret consisted of a single frontal plate, 130 mm thick, pressed into shape. The side armor is more speculative due to the lack of drawings, but would also have followed a similar process, albeit with a 125 mm thick plate.

Armament

The main weapon used on all KV-4 designs was the 107 mm ZiS-6 developed a few months earlier by Factory No.92 by V.G. Grabin by own initiative. With 800 to 840 m/s muzzle velocity and a 18.8 kg shell, it was a very potent anti-tank weapon, capable of penetrating 115 mm of armor at 1,000 m. The gun was tested in June and July on a KV-2 testbed and would enter production a few months later. However due to the KV-4 and subsequently KV-3 and KV-5 tanks never being built, the half-built guns had to be melted and recycled.

Secondary armament consisted of the 45 mm 20-K gun, used on the majority of Soviet light tanks at the time, as well as at least two 7.62 DT machine guns.

Death of LKZ’s Heavy Tanks

The Axis forces made quick progress into Soviet territory and by August were already approaching the city of Leningrad. To avoid capture and disruption of developments, many of the engineers of the SKB-2 design bureau were relocated to the Chelyabinsk Tractor Plant (ChTZ), which was renamed to Chelyabinsk Kirov Plant (ChKZ) upon their arrival. However, it was clear that the heavy tank developments in the form of the KV-3, KV-4, and KV-5 were more resource and financial pits for the Soviet defense than any actual help. The projects were all abandoned and development switched to improving the KV-1, which resulted in new successful vehicles, such as the KV-1S.

Conclusion

While, with hindsight, the entire KV-4 program ended up being a massive waste of resources, it is clear that some designs were fundamentally better than others, like the winning design by N.L. Dukhov. In contrast, the design by Marishkin was not particularly original and was not deemed as effective considering the liberal requirements and effective armament. Even today, his design is one of the lesser known and least appreciated designs from the program.

KV-4 (Object 223) Marishkin specifications
Dimensions (L-W-H)	8.7 – 3.8 – 3.5 m
Total Weight, Battle Ready	86.4 tonnes
Crew	7
Propulsion	1,200 hp diesel V-12 M-40 with 4 turbochargers
Speed	40 km/h (hypothetical)
Armament	107 mm ZiS-6 45 mm 20-K >2 DT 7.62 machine guns
Armor	Turret: 130 mm Frontal upper hull: 80 mm Frontal lower hull: 130 mm Side hull: 125 mm Rear hull: 125 mm Top: 40-50 mm Belly:40-50 mm
Total Production	0; blueprints only

Sources:

Breakthrough tank KV – Maxim Kolomiets
Stalin’s Supertanks IS-7 – Maxim Kolomiets
KV 163 1939-1941 – Maxim Kolomiets
Confrontation – Ibragimov Danyial Sabirovich
Constructor of Combat Vehicles – N.Popov
Bronevoy Schit Stalina. Istoriya Sovetskogo Tanka (1937-1943) M. Svirin
About the forgotten creators of Soviet armored power. (historyntagil.ru) – S.I. Pudovkin
German Lion | Warspot.ru – Yuri Pasholok
Крупный калибр для крупных КВ | Юрий Пашолок | Дзен (dzen.ru) – Yuri Pasholok
Tank building on the verge of common sense | Warspot.ru – Yuri Pasholok
Large caliber for large HF | Yuriy Pasholok | Yandex Zen – Yuri Pasholok
Tank Archives: Soviet 107 mm Guns – Peter Samsonov
Tank Archives: KV-3 Mulligan – Peter Samsonov
Tank Archives: Heavy Tank Costs – Peter Samsonov
Tank Archives: ZIS-6 Characteristics – Peter Samsonov
Marishkin F.A. (famhist.ru)